Blog

The New SEO: Why Optimising for ChatGPT and AI Search Engines Matters

MJP
Matthew J. Pyke
2 min read · 15 May 2025

The internet is entering a new era of search.

For decades, we built our websites and content to satisfy Google’s algorithm. Page rankings, click-through rates, keywords — these were the rules of the game.

But AI tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude are fundamentally changing how people find information.
They don’t just list links. They summarise, recommend, and answer — often without the user ever opening a browser tab.

This shift is huge.
We are moving from “search engines” to “answer engines.”

And here’s a reality check:
You can’t optimise for LLMs like you optimise for Google.
There are no special ranking factors or meta hacks for ChatGPT.
Instead, your best bet is to double down on the fundamentals:

  • Publish clear, high-authority content.

  • Get cited by credible sites.

  • Offer something original that’s worth surfacing.

In this piece, I’ll break down:

  • How LLMs are changing search behaviour,

  • What they look for when citing content,

  • And how businesses (and personal brands) can prepare for the future of online discovery.

AI is Replacing the Way We Find Information

When people want an answer today, they don’t always go to Google anymore.
They go to ChatGPT or Perplexity.ai and ask directly — expecting a clean, confident response without trawling through 10 websites.

This is the new expectation:
Faster answers. Less searching.

As a result, if you’re relying solely on traditional SEO tactics to drive traffic, you’re playing an outdated game.

Instead of fighting for a spot on Google’s first page, you need to be thinking:

  • How can I make my information trusted and clear enough that AI uses it?

  • How can I make my brand known, cited, and recommended by AI-driven tools?

You Can’t “Hack” LLMs — But You Can Prepare

Let me be clear:
You can’t “optimise” for LLMs in the traditional sense.
No technical SEO trick will make ChatGPT prioritise you.

But you can make your content the kind that LLMs naturally use:

  • Clear, accurate, evergreen information.

  • Topical authority: Become a recognised expert on a specific subject.

  • Citations and backlinks: Build credibility that AIs learn to trust.

  • Original research or unique insights: Something worth quoting.

Good SEO hasn’t become irrelevant — it has simply evolved.

Practical Steps to Stay Visible in the AI Era

If you want to futureproof your visibility:

  • Focus on answering real questions with clear, detailed content.

  • Publish original research, insights, or case studies.

  • Seek opportunities to be cited by major publications and trusted sources.

  • Keep your website technically sound and content fresh.

  • Organise your information with bullet points, lists, FAQs, and headings.

LLMs value clarity and credibility.
Your job is to provide both.

Closing Thoughts

Search is no longer about who can stuff the most keywords into a page.
It’s about who can earn trust, who can deliver answers, and who can contribute real value to an AI-driven ecosystem.

Those who adapt early will win.
Those who cling to the old SEO rules will gradually fade from view.

My advice:
Keep creating. Keep contributing. Stay clear, stay accurate, and stay original.
The future of search rewards the real experts.

Matthew J. Pyke
Written by

Matthew J. Pyke

Growth strategist and founder of Fly High Media. I help business owners connect marketing, sales and strategy into a growth system that actually compounds.

More about Matthew →
Read next

More thinking on growth.

View all articles →
Blog
11 min read · Matthew J. Pyke

AI Has Made Good Enough Worthless

There is a question I think a lot of business owners are asking quietly at the moment. “If AI can...

Read the article →
Blog
5 min read · Matthew J. Pyke

Alex Hormozi built the perfect Brand SEO Strategy

Most SEOs are still optimising pages while the rest of the search game has moved on. Here is what one...

Read the article →
Blog
4 min read · Matthew J. Pyke

PPC vs SEO: Which Delivers Better ROI for CMOs in a Rising-Cost Market?

When leadership teams review budgets, the conversation usually lands in the same place. Where does the next pound go? Paid...

Read the article →
Want the thinking applied?

Reading is useful. Building is better.

If this made you think differently about your growth, let’s talk about what it could look like inside your business.

Work with me →